Top tenant screening tools to reduce renter risk and protect your rent roll

When you're a landlord, every lease is a risk—and every renter represents either a steady stream of income or a potential liability. One missed payment can snowball into eviction costs, unit damage, legal headaches, and months of vacancy. So how do you reduce renter risk without slowing down your leasing process?

It all starts with tenant screening. It's crucial to choose a tenant screening tool that is appropriate for your property size, leasing volume, and operational style.

In this post, we’ll break down how to streamline tenant screening, explore the top platforms used by landlords and institutional operators, and share real-world examples to help you pick the right fit. Whether you’re managing 5 units or 5,000, using the right tools can protect your rent roll and your reputation.

Why tenant screening matters more than ever

Late rent and evictions aren’t just financial issues—they’re operational ones. For institutional landlords, a single bad tenant can lead to:

• $2,000–$5,000 in eviction and legal fees
• $1,500+ in repairs and turnover costs
• 1–3 months of lost rent during vacancy
• Internal labor hours spent on screening, follow-up, collections, and re-leasing

And if you're managing hundreds of doors, that damage scales fast. That's why screening isn't just a task—it's a defense strategy.

What makes a great tenant screening tool?

Before diving into the list, let’s align on what actually makes a screening service effective:

✅ Credit + Criminal Background Reports
✅ Eviction History Reports
✅ Income Verification
✅ Automation/Ease of Use
✅ Fraud Detection Capabilities
✅ Flexible payment setup (landlord or renter pays)

The goal? To verify tenant reliability metrics before signing the lease—and avoid being blindsided later.

The best tenant screening tools by use case

1. For independent landlords who want a plug-and-play option: SmartMove by TransUnion

SmartMove is an excellent tool for landlords who don’t want to jump through hoops. You don’t need to get FCRA-certified or have your office inspected because the renter initiates the report directly.

SmartMove includes:

• ResidentScore (TransUnion’s proprietary scoring model, tailored to predict renter behavior)
• Income Insights (estimates ability to pay rent)
• Credit, criminal, and eviction data

Pricing: $25–$45 per report, depending on package
Real-world bonus: One landlord in Denver shared that SmartMove flagged a recent eviction that wasn’t yet on a standard credit report—saving them from leasing to a repeat defaulter.

🔗 Check it out here

2. For property owners who want more than just screening: Avail by Realtor.com

Avail is a full-service property management platform designed for smaller portfolios. It integrates tenant screening through SmartMove but also gives you tools for

• Rent collection
• Maintenance tracking
• Digital leases
• Rent price analysis

Avail is a fantastic option if you want everything in one place.

Cost: Free tier available; premium costs $9/unit/month
Pro tip: Avail allows applicants to pay for their own reports, which makes it easier for landlords who are cost-conscious to adopt the service.

🔗 Visit Avail

3. For growing landlords who need flexible leasing support: Hemlane

Hemlane isn’t just screening software—it’s a hybrid platform that lets you outsource parts of your property management process while still keeping control.

Its screening service includes:

• Soft credit checks
• Nationwide criminal background data
• Eviction reports
• Income verification tools

Hemlane also offers 24/7 repair coordination and leasing support—ideal for landlords scaling from 10 to 100+ units.

Pricing: $30/month base package with screening included

4. For enterprise-scale PMCs: Appfolio and Buildium

If you're managing hundreds or thousands of units, you need more than background checks. You need a system that integrates with your accounting, maintenance, leasing, and analytics tools.

Appfolio and Buildium are the gold standard for enterprise property managers.

They offer:

• Deep integrations with credit bureaus
• Instant ID verification and fraud detection
• On-site inspections (required for some credit checks)
• Customizable approval workflows

These systems are not cheap, but their cost is easily justified by the scale, automation, and consistency they bring to large portfolios.

Pricing: Varies by portfolio size and feature set.

5. Honorable mentions for niche use cases

• E-Renter: Ideal if you want screening without tenant initiation, and includes bank data insights.
• RentPrep: Offers both SmartMove bundles and alternative reports, great for smaller landlords.
• Innago: Combines screening with rent collection and maintenance ticket tracking in one free platform.
• RentSpree: Integrates directly with MLS for real estate agents managing rentals.

‍

‍

And always ask yourself:

• Who’s paying for the screening?
• Do I need help beyond screening (leases, payments, maintenance)?
• Is it scalable if I add 50 more units next year?

Don’t forget this final layer: rent protection

Even the best tenant screening tools can’t catch everything. People lose jobs, have life events, or slip through the cracks. That’s where rent protection services like lease guarantees come in.

Combining thorough screening with a rent guarantor (such as Cosign) gives landlords true peace of mind. Even if a tenant defaults, your rental income stream is protected.

Consider it as the shield that protects your initial line of defense.

Final thoughts

Tenant screening has advanced significantly since the days of paper forms and intuition. With the right tools, landlords can screen faster, smarter, and more confidently.

Whether you're a first-time landlord with 3 units or managing 3,000 across the country, there's a screening solution that fits your operations—and your risk appetite.

The right screening process doesn’t just prevent losses. It sets you up for consistent occupancy, less turnover, and a portfolio that grows with confidence.